The best Thanksgiving menus strike a balance between beloved nostalgia and bright, seasonal freshness. You want the comforting classics everyone looks forward to all year—golden rolls, velvety potatoes, deeply savory dressing, and flaky pies—alongside vibrant autumn flavors that wake up the palate and keep the meal from feeling heavy.
Whether you are hosting the whole family or contributing a standout dish to the spread, we’ve gathered a curated mix of our favorite Thanksgiving recipes from the archives alongside a few brand-new autumn additions from our kitchen. From foolproof turkey brines to brown-butter pies and next-day breakfast loaves, here is everything you need to plan a thoughtful, flavor-packed holiday menu.
3 Chef Tips for Stress-Free Thanksgiving Hosting
1. Lean into make-ahead dishes (and room-temperature stars) If you wait until the day of to start making everything, you’re already behind! You shouldn’t be chained to the stove while guests are arriving. Build your menu around components that actually taste better when prepped a day or two early—like brining your turkey ahead, simmering the cranberry sauce, shaking up your vinaigrettes, and baking pies and quick breads the day before. Even your roasted beets can be cooked and peeled in advance, leaving only quick assembly on Thursday.
2. Set up a self-serve grazing spot and pre-batch a signature drink or have wine out and open for guests to pour a glass The final hour before dinner is when you need your hands free for carving, tossing salads, and pulling rolls from the oven—not playing bartender or fielding "when are we eating?" questions. Set out an effortless nibble (like warm Bacon Gougères or spiced nuts and cheese) alongside bottles of wine, a pre-batched holiday cocktail or pitcher punch in another room so guests have a natural place to gather, sip, and mingle while you put the finishing touches on the meal.
3. Stock the counter for Thanksgiving morning (and Friday leftovers) When houseguests wake up early or linger in the kitchen while you prep, having a ready-to-slice loaf like spiced pumpkin bread or cranberry orange bread alongside a pot of coffee takes all the pressure off breakfast—and doubles as an effortless afternoon snack before the main meal.
The Centerpiece & Essential Condiments
3 Turkey Brines for the Juiciest Bird Ever A truly memorable Thanksgiving turkey starts long before it hits the oven. Whether you lean toward classic aromatics, warm spices, or bright citrus notes, these three brines lock in moisture and build deep flavor from the inside out. Get the 3 Turkey Brines recipe
Cinnamon Port Cranberry Sauce Skip the can—simmering fresh cranberries with ruby port and warm cinnamon yields a glossy, jewel-toned sauce with just the right balance of tartness and spice. It’s incredible alongside turkey and just as good spread onto leftover sandwiches the next day. Get the Cinnamon Port Cranberry Sauce recipe
Vibrant Salads & Autumn Starters
Roasted Beet and Arugula Salad with Blue Cheese and Fennel Seed Brittle Every rich holiday table needs something crisp, peppery, and bright. Steam-roasting the beets under foil keeps them velvety tender and makes peeling effortless, while rich Pedro Ximénez sherry vinegar, creamy blue cheese, sweet orange supremes, and a shatteringly crisp homemade fennel seed brittle make every bite feel restaurant-worthy. Get the Roasted Beet and Arugula Salad recipe
Mixed Greens Salad with Toasted Walnuts, Goat Cheese & Cranberry Vinaigrette Festive, colorful, and effortless to assemble, this salad pairs crisp greens with creamy goat cheese, toasted walnuts, and a tart cranberry dressing. (Want an even faster 5-ingredient option? Whisk up our mason-jar Apple Butter Vinaigrette to toss with your favorite bitter greens and shaved Brussels sprouts.) Get the Mixed Greens Salad recipe | Get the Apple Butter Vinaigrette recipe
Bacon Gougères Warm, airy French cheese puffs studded with savory bacon are the ultimate way to welcome guests with a glass of sparkling wine while the turkey rests. Get the Bacon Gougères recipe
Comforting & Seasonal Side Dishes
Silky Mashed Potatoes with Celeriac Adding earthy celery root (celeriac) to classic mashed potatoes brings a subtle, aromatic depth that elevates a staple without straying too far from tradition—and makes them the ultimate vessel for gravy. Get the Silky Mashed Potatoes with Celeriac recipe
Orange and Ginger Sweet Potato Puree If you love sweet potatoes on the holiday table but prefer something a little more sophisticated than a marshmallow-topped casserole, this is your answer. Roasting the sweet potatoes whole concentrates their natural sweetness before they’re whipped with fresh orange zest, warming grated ginger, butter, and a touch of sorghum. Get the Orange and Ginger Sweet Potato Puree recipe
Cornbread Dressing (Gluten Free) Baked with our Cornbread with Fresh-Milled Cornmeal, this deeply savory, herb-flecked dressing proves that gluten-free holiday sides never have to feel like an afterthought. Get the Gluten-Free Cornbread Dressing recipe
Brussel Sprouts with Bacon and Pomegranate Charred, crispy-edged Brussels sprouts tossed with smoky bacon and jewel-like pomegranate arils bring a pop of color, crunch, and bright acidity to the plate. Get the Brussel Sprouts with Bacon and Pomegranate recipe
Patrick’s Southern Collard Greens Slow-simmered until tender and rich with smoky, savory potlikker, Patrick’s collard greens bring unmistakable Southern comfort and balance to a classic Thanksgiving spread. Get Patrick’s Southern Collard Greens recipe
Butternut Squash Casserole with Vanilla Wafer Topping Velvety roasted butternut squash meets a crisp, golden vanilla wafer crumb topping in this playful, crowd-pleasing twist on a classic holiday casserole. It brings just the right hint of sweet nostalgia to balance out the savory dishes on the table. Get the Butternut Squash Casserole recipe
Warm Breads & Holiday Weekend Loaves
Honey Butter Sage Brioche Rolls Soft, pillowy, and swirled with fragrant fresh sage and sweet honey butter, these pull-apart rolls will disappear before the platters even make it around the table. Get the Honey Butter Sage Brioche Rolls recipe
Cranberry Orange Bread with Fresh Ginger and Toasted Walnuts Having a bakery-style loaf on the counter is a lifesaver when houseguests wake up early—or for a quiet morning slice with coffee the day after the feast. Studded with tart fresh cranberries, toasted walnuts, grated ginger, and a whisper of sumac, it’s finished with a thick orange-blossom glaze. Get the Cranberry Orange Bread recipe
Rye Pumpkin Bread with Maple Glaze Earthy rye flour brings wonderful depth and subtle nuttiness to classic spiced pumpkin bread. Drizzled with a rich maple glaze, it’s a cozy, from-scratch loaf made for slow holiday mornings or an afternoon snack between meals. Get the Rye Pumpkin Bread recipe
From-Scratch Pies & Autumn Desserts
Brown Butter Maple Pumpkin Pie Toasting the butter until nutty and golden before whisking it into spiced pumpkin puree and pure maple syrup transforms classic pumpkin pie into something truly unforgettable. Get the Brown Butter Maple Pumpkin Pie recipe
Chocolate Pecan Pie Rich dark chocolate melted into a classic toasted-pecan custard gives this Southern staple a bittersweet, decadent edge that balances the sweetness of the filling. Get the Chocolate Pecan Pie recipe
Apple Galette with Rye & Cheddar Crust For guests who prefer fruit desserts—or a subtle savory-sweet finish—tender spiced apples baked inside a flaky, nutty rye and sharp cheddar pastry crust hit every note. (If you’re feeding a crowd, our Maple Pecan Chiffon Cake with Brown Butter Icing is another incredible make-ahead option!) Get the Apple Galette recipe | Get the Maple Pecan Chiffon Cake recipe
Hosting Made Effortless
If your calendar is already overflowing—or you simply want to sit back and enjoy your guests without spending days at the stove—we would love to cook for you. We still have a select few dates available for intimate holiday dinners and seasonal gatherings at home. Inquire About Private Dining & Holiday Menus